Sunday, April 15, 2012

One More Observation: Upside Down Jonah



One more thing I would like to draw attention to before I give this subject a rest for a while is what I see as one of the more interesting problems of context for interpreting the name "Yonah" on this ossuary.

Very simply put, if the "fish," as a fish, is facing "left" then that puts the inscription interpreted as "Yonah" nearly upside-down.

This -- as can been seen -- does not provide a favorable context as it leaves the frames of reference for each claim quite literally at odds.

Thoughts?

Peace,
-Steve

2 comments:

  1. As I understand the original image has the head pointing down.
    Try rotating it to the right.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, on the original ossuary it is in a "downward" orientation. However, in the initial press kits and the documentary (in fact, this still is *taken* from the documentary) *this* is the orientation where the supposed "fish" is "up" (in fact, how they show it "floating away").

    In order to read "Yonah", one must turn the "fish" upside-down relative to this frame, which is at odds with this supposition.

    With all of this "flopping around like a fish" necessary for all of the pieces to fit, I believe that this is further evidence towards this motif simply being a decorated vessel.

    Peace,
    -Steve

    ReplyDelete

There are several rules about commenting here:

1) All unsigned/anonymous comments will be temp-deleted. I would like the actual names of the people who comment here.

2) SPAM will be deleted outright and permanently.

3) If someone is obnoxious, I will temp-delete their comments until they become more civil.

4) By commenting here, you release the copyrights of your comments to me.

Other than that, have fun. :-)